Tenants – Who’s Fixture Is It? Check Your Lease!

Posted by Lee Sterling | Posted in Economics, Landlord-Tenant, Legal, Miscellaneous, Negotiation, Real Estate | Posted on 08-06-2012

Did your tenant representative  reminded you to review what happens to your fixtures at the end of the initial term        of your lease, and what happens if you renew the lease? And did your representative describe what might be a trade fixture and what might be a fixture? California has described fixtures as “a fixture is a thing that is so attached to realty as to be considered in law a part of the realty itself,” and a trade fixture as a “[fixtures] placed on leased premises for the purposes of trade.”  Absent specific language  in the lease, a tenant has no right to remove fixtures at the end of the lease term, but MAY remove trade fixtures during the term (and for a reasonable time after the end of the term) “if the removal can be effected without injury to the premises…”

 Another complication arises if you holdover, renew or extend your lease. California has determined that if you holdover, that means staying in the premises after the term of your lease has ended, absent specific language to the contrary, the fixtures AND the trade fixtures become the property of the landlord.  And if there’s nothing in the renewal of the lease that allows you to remove the fixtures or trade fixtures that were installed during the initial term you may have lost the right to remove them at the end of the renewal term.

What’s obvious is that a seemingly simple provision in a lease may be more complicated than the average tenant may understand.  That’s why you need to  make sure that you review your lease carefully, get good advice from your tenant representative, and have your lease reviewed by a competent California real estate attorney. There are lots more of these “gotcha” clauses in a typical “standard” lease.